This Commission has already held in different appeals that documents submitted by firms/individuals to a public body for contracts are public documents as these documents reveal level of competence of the firms/individuals to carry out tasks funded by the tax-payers of the country. Download Order
The appellant requested the complete evaluation report carried out by LESCOin pursuance of tender no 354/PMU for procurement for 2/5 nos of accuracy class 0.2s energy meters upon which LESCO has issued purchase order no.334 dateed 16-10-2019 in addition to amendment no.01 in purchase order no.334 dated 11-03-2020… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 856-01/21 Pervaz Iqbal Vs Lahore Electric Supply Company
The Appellant has filed appeal dated 3.5.2021 before the Pakistan Information Commission under the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017 read with Article 19A of the Constitution of Pakistan complaining therein for non-provision of the requested information by the Cantonment Board Faisal, Karachi with in the frame… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 1113-06-2021 Asad H. Kizilbash Vs Cantonment Board Faisal, Karachi
The appellant requested Pakistan Medical Commission for the provision of complete file, minutes of meeting and video recording of the hearing of disciplinary committee held in pursuance of his complaint vide no PF.8.1641/2018-Legal-DC. The President, Pakistan Medical Commission is directed to provide the requested information within 10 working… Read More »Order on Appeal No. E76-01/21 Wajahat Ahmed Ghous Vs Pakistan Medical Commission
This commission is of the view that the relationship of employees whose services have been hired by Cantonment Board, Malir through a contractor to carry out cleaning / sweeping / garbage collection / waste disposal etc performed in the Cantonment areas Cantonment Board, Malir is already settled in… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 950-03/21 Naeem Sadiq Vs Cantonment Board Malir Karachi
This commission is of the view that the request to have access to the last two audit reports of IESSI and when was the audit conducted last time, total number of the sanctioned posts in the department, along with the details of the vacant posts (pay scale wise… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 1075-04/21 Nadeem Umer Vs Social Security Islamabad
This commission is of the view that the requested information pertaining to the list of the organizations / companies / factories / hotels etc registered with the Social Security, Islamabad along with the details of such as total number of their employees, addresses, security (social security fee) submitted… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 1011-04/21 Nadeem Umer Vs Social Security Islamabad
The Appeal is dismissed as harm from disclosure outweighs public interest if the private entity chooses the path of arbitration resulting in severe financial penalties for the country because of the confidentiality clauses in Share Purchase Agreement dated 14.11.2005, other related documents, agreements and communication. Secretary, Privatization Commission… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 512-08/20 M. Tariq Mansoor Vs Ministry of Privatisation
The appellant have requested information the appeal dated 03-01-2019 titled ‘appeal u/s 468 of the Companies Act 2017, against order dated 08-10-2018, received on 8-12-2018, under Companies Act 2017, Failure to issue certified copies of forms / or Failure to receive special return dated 8-9-2018, violation of statutory… Read More »Order on Appeal No.963-3-2021 Miss Saira Javed Vs Security and Exchange Commission of Pakistan
The appellants has requested provision of the merit list, answer sheets and answer keys under the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017 from the office of Deputy Secretary Admin/ Public Information Officer, Ministry of Narcotics Control, Islamabad. The respondent public body in its reply has pleaded the… Read More »Order on Appeal No. E-102-03-2021, E-103-03-2021, E-95-03-2021 Mohammad Saqib, Aftab Ahmed , Bilal Ahmed Vs Ministry of Narcotics