The appellant in the instant appeal has requested the following information from Establishment Division Minutes of the meeting of the Central Selection Board (CSB) held on 4th to 7th January 2021; List of the civil servants who were considered for promotion to the BS-20 but were either superseded… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1091-05/21 Mukhtar Ahmed Ali Vs Establishment Division
In the instant appeal, the citizen has asked for copies of assets declaration of last three years from 1st July to 30th June 2022 submitted by five most senior BPS 20, BPS 21 and BPS 22 government employees of all 12 cadres are below mentioned and other non-cadre.… Read More »Order on Appeal No 2133-08/22 Muhammad Adeel Akram Vs Establishment Division
In the instant appeal, the Respondent failed to provide written acknowledgement of the request for information filed by the citizen as required under Section 10 (1) of the Act. The Respondent also failed in adhering to the timeline for responding to the information requests as required under Section… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1821-03/22 Aashir Ali Vs Establishment Division
This commission holds that if relevant sections of the Government Servants (Conduct) Rules, 1964 pertaining to the assets details of those who are paid from the government exchequer, are implemented, the citizens of Pakistan, who pay taxes for, inter alia, the salaries of civil servants, will be able… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1925-05/22 Sharafat Ali Zia Vs Establishment Division
The appellant has requested the Establishment Division for information regarding total strength of officers currently serving in the OMG, Number of officers in the OMG recruited through direct appointment, Number of officers in the OMG appointed by promotion, Number of posts currently vacant in the OMG and other.… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 2014-06/2022 Omer Qayuum Vs Establishment Division
This commission maintains that the disclosure of the IPC Formula / minutes of meeting dated 19-09-1993 and information about Cadre strength of PAS does not hit any of the exemption clauses mentioned in Section 7 or Section 16 of the Act. In fact, the disclosure of the IPC… Read More »Order on Appeal No 505-08/21 & 390-06/20 Tariq Mahmood Awan, Murtaza Hashim Vs Establishment Division
This commission maintains that as far as the date and the method of the approval of the requested information about “the draft rules framed by the Chairman Federal Public Service Commission for CSS Examination” is concerned, this requested information is also available with the Cabinet Division in the… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1439-11/21 Irfan Jahangir Wattoo Vs Cabinet Division and Establishment Division
In the instant Appeal the appellant herein instead asking for any specific information or record available with the public bodies in printed or digital form has raised a set of interrogations and questions built on his allegations and claims against the department. He has made his own arguments… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1259-08/2021, 1260-08/2021, 1261-08/2021 M. Saleem Butt Vs Establishment Division, Ministry of Law and Justice & Federal Board of Revenue
Establishment Division is directed to provide the list of the officers who have not submitted their assets declaration form during the period of the 2017, 2018 and 2019 along with the details of the action taken against those officers who did not submitted their assets declaration. The public… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 295-02/20 Shehzad Ahmed Khan Vs Establishment Division
Public Information Officer, Establishment Division is directed to provide the following requested information to the Applicant, with intimation to this commission, within 10 working days of the receipt of this Order: “Whether it is a fact that large number of the government officers are not submitting their assets… Read More »Order on Appeal No. 761-12/20 Nadeem Umer Vs Establishment Division