This commission concurs with the Respondent that the ‘opinions’ sought by the Appellant from the Respondent, Ministry of Law and Justice do not fall under definition of information given in sub section V of Section (2) of Information Act, 2017. This commission also holds that the requested information… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1514-12/21 Kashif Ali Sundrani Vs Ministry of Law & Justice
This commission holds that requested “list of Journalist and media workers, who got plot under their respective quota or under any other law or orders/ direction of higher authorities in different sectors of Islamabad since 1980 to till date” is public information under the provisions of the Act,… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1117-06/21 Syed Ishteyaq Mustafa Bukhary Vs Capital Development Authority
The Appellant has the right to have access to ‘noting on the file’ pertaining to the letter issued by the AIG (HQ) _ Finance regarding alleged irregularities in the reward list, as the Awards list has already been finalised to know that the alleged irregularities, if any, have… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1451-11/21 Bushra Perveen Vs National Highway & Motorway Police
The appellant through his application has asked for the certified copies of marked answer sheets of all successful and unsuccessful candidates who appeared in written test for admission in PhD anthropology held online on September 13, 2021. The asking respondent has refused the provision of the same claiming… Read More »Order on Appeal No E165-10-2021 Muhammad Shahid Khan Vs Quaid-i-Azam University
The appellant has asked for the enquiry report on his application addressed to the D.G, NADRA. The issues raised by the appellant in his application cannot be resolved by the NADRA authorities rather they are bound to implement the orders of the court of law. The alleged issues… Read More »Order on Appeal 1311-09-2021 Mumtaz Hussain Vs National Database & Registration Authority
The appellant has asked for the provision of the certified Rate-List of existing annual land lease / compensation rates per acre per annum, paid to land owners of all categories / phases i.e. producing phase, drilling phase, settled, unsettled lands etc. of all the regions/ districts/ fields or… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1191-07-2021 Kashif Ali Sundrani Vs Pakistan Petroleum Limited
The appellant has asked for the provision of the certified Rate-List of existing annual Land Lease/Rental compensation and temporary Land Acquisition Rated per Acre per Annum or hired Lands for Pipe Lines/ Plants/ Field of all the Regional / District/fields, per Acre permanently acquired by SNGC since 2016… Read More »Order on Appeal No 1435-11-2021 Kashif Ali Sundrani Vs Sui Northern Gas Company Limited