From the contents of the appeal it is found that the appellant has made request that he is require certified copies of approved minutes of PCP’s meeting dated 15-05-2008 and 01-10-2010 vide which penalty was imposed on account of over and above enrollment without considering the record and… Read More »Order on Appeal No: 2509-02/23 Kaleem Ahmed Vs Pharmacy Council of Pakistan
In the instant case, it is observed that the point raised does not related to an information but only a question which does not constitute an “information” within the meaning of RTI Act, 2017. Therefore, the appeal does not lie within jurisdiction of Pakistan Information Commission, hence, does… Read More »Order in Appeal No: 1352-09/21 Irfan Jehangir Wattoo Vs Federal Public Service Commission
In the instant appeal, the appellant has sought copy of an enquiry report which was held against him. The respondent public body has raised objection that as per Section 6 of the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017, the record of inquiry is not public record hence… Read More »Order on Appeal No: 2301-10/22 Tariq Rahim Vs Pakistan International Airline
Under Section 17 of Right of Access to Information Act, 2017 an applicant who is not satisfied by the decision of designated official by him within the time fixed. He may, within the period not exceeding 30 days after either receiving the decision or after the time limit… Read More »Order on Appeal No: 2297-10/2022 Dr. Saeed Ahmed Vs Oil and Gas Development Company – OGDCL
In the instant appeal, the appellant has sought copy of an enquiry report which was held against him under show cause notice no. CDU-12-2021-003 DATED 06/12/2021. The respondent public body has raised objection that as per Section 6 of the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017, the… Read More »Order on Appeal No: 2298-10/22 Farooq-e-Azam Vs Pakistan International Airline
The appellant, while filing appeal dated 26-9-22, submitted that the respondent FPSC, while appearing before the Hon’ble Lahore High Court, Lahore through its letter dated 23-12-2021 made the following reply: “the recruitment process is carried out in the light of notified recruitment rules and as per general instructions… Read More »Order on Appeal No: 2282-10/22 Omer Jehangir Vs Federal Public Service Commission
The requested information about appeal mechanisms and orders on representations is not available on the web site of the Respondent, President Secretariat. The representative of the President Secretariat submitted before the Commission that the web site is in the process of upgradation. Once it is updated, all categories… Read More »Order on Appeal No 2147-08/22 Malik Umar Vs President Secretariat
This Commission holds that the stance of the Respondent that the proceedings on the instant appeal be warrant sine die adjournment as two Writ Petitions on the similar subject are pending for adjudication in the Islamabad High Court, Islamabad does not hold water. The matter under the consideration… Read More »Order on Appeal No 2033-06/22 Aamir Baloch Vs Registrar, Islamabad High Court
This commission has already settled the identical matter in Appeal No. 2102-08/2022, In the case of Atif Chaudhary Vs Election Commission of Pakistan and held that searchable electoral list on a UBS can be provided to an Appellant under Section 79 (3) of the Elections Act, 2017 which… Read More »Order on Appeal No 2015-08/22 Muhammad Akram Usman Vs Election Commission of Pakistan
Information Commissioner, Zahid Abdullah in his dissenting note has stated that there is no stigma attached with free treatment if a person cannot afford such a treatment. In other words, there is no invasion of privacy if community comes to know that a particular individual got treatment for… Read More »Dissenting Note of Information Commissioner Zahid Abdullah On Order Nadeem Umer Vs Al-Shifa Trust